Good Puppers, Too! contains 100 new unique cards, depicting nine new breeds of pup and one group of Rascals. The core mechanics of the game are the same: Draft pups, play them, and they will perform tricks that allow groups of pups to bury bones. Bones are worth points, and can be upgraded by various tricks to be worth more points, and end-game bonuses can upgrade them as well.

The new Rascals have Schemes! If you complete a Scheme, that group of pups will double all their points at the end of the game.

Good Puppers, Too! can be played on its own, mixed with some cards from Good Puppers, or combined with Good Puppers to make a mega-pup game that can hold up to 7 players.